Metavid

Video archive of the US Congress

House Proceeding 11-07-09 on Nov 7th, 2009 :: 1:32:30 to 1:52:30
Total video length: 8 hours 10 minutes Stream Tools: Stream Overview | Edit Time

Note: MetaVid video transcripts may contain inaccuracies, help us build a more perfect archive

Download OptionsEmbed Video

Views:579 Duration: 0:20:00 Discussion

Previous speech: Next speech:

Rodney P. Frelinghuysen

1:31:25 to 1:32:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Rodney P. Frelinghuysen

Rodney P. Frelinghuysen

1:32:26 to 1:32:31( Edit History Discussion )

Rodney P. Frelinghuysen: ability to afford their health insurance. and they are worried with good reason.

Barney Frank

1:32:32 to 1:32:53( Edit History Discussion )

Barney Frank: they ah good i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california. mr. waxman: mr. speaker, at this time i yield one minute to the gentleman from massachusetts, mr. frank, for the purpose of colloquy. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. frank: i thank the chairman. i congratulate him for the excellent work he and others have done on this bill. and i want t

Barney Frank

1:32:35 to 1:33:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Barney Frank

Barney Frank

1:32:54 to 1:33:14( Edit History Discussion )

Barney Frank: importance of the bill in addressing hard to reach communities, including commercial fishermen who aren impo constituency, but also farmers and ranchers. ranchers tend to be a less important part of my constituency. we are create agnew health insurance marketplace and requiring health coverage which i support. this makes it particularly important to educate those that haven't had

Barney Frank

1:33:15 to 1:33:35( Edit History Discussion )

Barney Frank: access to quality affordable health care. under the bill, will the community be able to contract with entities to facilitate the dissemination of information? mr. waxman: thens answer is yes. mr. frank: i thank the gentleman. this means i assume the commissioner can work with the small with this sort of outreach

Barney Frank

1:33:36 to 1:33:51( Edit History Discussion )

Barney Frank: mr. waxman: yes. the bill shows the commissioners business administration. mr. frank: i thank the chairman for clarifying these points. section 2229 of the senate bill recognizes the unique health care educational outreacneeds

Joseph R. Pitts

1:33:52 to 1:34:13( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: of commercial fishermen, farmers and rancope that will be accepted in the final bill. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. the gentleman from texas. mr. barton: mr. speaker, i am proud to recognize one of the strong pro-life leaders in the u.s. congress, combat veteran of vietnam, member of the energy and commerce committee, the

Joseph R. Pitts

1:33:55 to 1:35:15( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Joseph R. Pitts

Joseph R. Pitts

1:34:14 to 1:34:34( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: pennsylvania, for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. pitts: thank you, mr. speaker. there's been some recent confusions surrounding the inclusion of abortion coverage in 3962. but the issue's actually quite clear. the capps amendment in the bill which some have argued is neutral on abortion explicitly authorizes the federal government to directly fund

Joseph R. Pitts

1:34:35 to 1:34:56( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: elective abortions using federal funds drawn om a federal treasury account. the provision has been build as a so-called compromise amendment. but this bill will radically expand current and long-standing federal policy with respect to abortion. currently there's not a single government health care program that provides coverage for elective abortion, not schip,

Joseph R. Pitts

1:34:57 to 1:35:16( Edit History Discussion )

Joseph R. Pitts: not medicaid, not d.o.d., indian health, or the federal employee health benefit program all because of congressional action to explicitly prohibit coverage of abortion under each of these programs. but such an explicit exclusion is missing from this bill. therefore i urge my colleagues to support when it comes up later the stupak, pits, chris

Kathy Castor

1:35:17 to 1:35:37( Edit History Discussion )

Kathy Castor: smith, kaptur amendment that would prevent federal funding of abortion in this bill. i thank you. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california. mr. waxman: i yield one minute to the gentlelady from florida, member of o castor. the speaker pro tempore: the gent one minute. ms. castor: thank you, mr. speaker. mr. speaker, democrats will now deliver on what american

Kathy Castor

1:35:20 to 1:36:40( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Kathy Castor

Kathy Castor

1:35:38 to 1:35:59( Edit History Discussion )

Kathy Castor: families and businesses have been asking for when it their health. one meaningful secure and stable insurance, two, improved medicare for seniors. three, vital consumer protections. for families with health insurance, health reform will provide you with coverage you can count on. families will no longer have to worry about insurance companies canceling their coverage because

Kathy Castor

1:36:00 to 1:36:21( Edit History Discussion )

Kathy Castor: someone in their family gets sick. health insurance companies will no longer be able to bar you from insurance because you have diabetes, cancer, or some other chronic condition. american families have been doing everything right. they have been paying their co-pays, paying their premiums, even as those cost vs. risen dramatically. our health bill says in return that coverage must be

Kathy Castor

1:36:22 to 1:36:40( Edit History Discussion )

Kathy Castor: meaningful, stable, and secure. and for our family members who rely on medicare, you will see immediate improvements in your prescriptions, checkups, and measures i worked on to penalize unscrupulous practices of private medicare insurance agents. the meaningful health reform

Cynthia Lummis

1:36:41 to 1:37:01( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: builds on the great legacies of social security and medicare. i'm proud to represent florida's families in this historic vote. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas. mr. barton: i want to represe the gentlelady from wyoming, who represents the congresswoman lummis, for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlewoman is recognized for

Cynthia Lummis

1:36:45 to 1:38:45( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Cynthia Lummis

Cynthia Lummis

1:37:02 to 1:37:23( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: one minute. mrs. lummis: i stand before you today on behalf of the people of wyoming where individual freedom and personal respsibility are hallmark values. this trillion dollar tax erybody right down to the wheelchair debacle will impact every person in wyoming. this bill will force my constituents to buy insurance

Cynthia Lummis

1:37:24 to 1:37:44( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: whether it makes sense for them or not. this bill will dump some of my constituents into a government-run health care program to which members of congress will not even subject themselves. i sought an amendment that would allow states to shield their citizens from government forced

Cynthia Lummis

1:37:45 to 1:38:06( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: insurance, from taxes and possible fines or imprisonment. from government policies that come between themselves and their doctors. from unfunded mandates on stes. but my amendment and dozens of others were swept away by the majority and american freedoms right along with it.

Cynthia Lummis

1:38:07 to 1:38:28( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: our constitution was designed to empower the american people and shackle the federal government. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady's time has expired. mrs. lummis: this bill will shackle the american people e empowering the federal government. in wyoming, mr. speaker. i yield back. mr. waxman: i yld to

Cynthia Lummis

1:38:29 to 1:38:45( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: gentleman from pennsylvania -- the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman will withhold. the chair will remind all persons in the gallery that are here as guests of the and that any manifestaon of approval o proceedings or other audible conversation is in violatio

1:38:46 to 1:39:06( Edit History Discussion )

the rules of the house. mr. waxman: i'm pleased to yield one minute to the gentleman from pennsylvania, mr. murphy, who has been a leader in our efforts to lower growth in premiums through measures such immediate review and justification of an insurer rate increase. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. murphy: thank you, mr. speaker. thank you, mr. chairman.

1:39:07 to 1:39:27( Edit History Discussion )

colleagues, voting yes today means tax incentives for joe frederick, a small business owner in bucks county, pennsylvania, who struggles with skyrocketing health care costs for his employees. it's a vote for mr. sinclair whose niece died because she's couldn't get insurance. it's a vote for joe who was

Patrick Murphy

1:39:28 to 1:39:48( Edit History Discussion )

Patrick Murphy: kicked off his plan after being diagnosed with lou gehrig's disease. i urge a yes vote for our fellow americans who want secure, affordable health insurance who can't be taken away from them when they need it most. 16 years have passed since we last tried to reform health care. premiums have more than doubled. every day in the state of

Patrick Murphy

1:39:30 to 1:40:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Patrick Murphy

Patrick Murphy

1:39:49 to 1:40:13( Edit History Discussion )

Patrick Murphy: pennsylvania, 510 families are kicked off their coverage. that's every single day. mr. chairman, as i said proud blog democrat and there is universal agreement that many to get our country's fiscal house back in order we must first get our health care spending under control. and this bill does just that. it actually reduces our deficit

Patrick Murphy

1:40:14 to 1:40:35( Edit History Discussion )

Patrick Murphy: by $129. taking important steps -- $129 billion. taking important steps to rein in heah care costs. but there is more work to be done. i look forward to working with you and our leadership to accomplish this goal. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. mr. waxman: i yield myself another 10 seconds. if the gentleman would permit. i want to thank you leadership and assure you that we are going to continue to work

Patrick Murphy

1:40:36 to 1:40:50( Edit History Discussion )

Patrick Murphy: in conference to do everything we can to make coverage affordable for the american people. mr. murphy: i urge my colleague to vote yes the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas. mr. barton: i want to recognize

Lee Terry

1:40:51 to 1:41:11( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: for one minute, mr. lee terry, who represents his hometow omaha, nebraska, the home of the college world series. one minute. the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. terry: it's clear that skyrocketing health care costs do exist causing a number of americans to become uninsured. but instead of addressing these issues, the

Lee Terry

1:41:05 to 1:42:00( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Lee Terry

Lee Terry

1:41:12 to 1:41:32( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: us a bill that dramatically care system. it injects government into every corner of health care decisionmaking from arming the health choices commissioner with unprecedented power to dictate coverage and influence costs, and imposing crushing taxes on small businesses. it transfers $600 billion from

Lee Terry

1:41:33 to 1:41:54( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: medicare and medicaid. and imposes mandates on states by expanding medicaid which w then trickle down and force the states and the localities to have to increase taxes, really masking true cost of this massive $1.2 trillion bill.

Lee Terry

1:41:55 to 1:42:02( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: there is a better way that we can accomplish providing americans with affordable health care.

Chris Murphy

1:42:03 to 1:42:24( Edit History Discussion )

Chris Murphy: i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california. mr. waxman: i yield one minute connecticut, mr. murphy. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. murphy: thank you very much, mr. chairman. every night in my state thousands of kids go to sleep sick in their bed just because their mother can't afford to get them to a doctor. this is the most affluent, most compassionate nation in the

Chris Murphy

1:42:05 to 1:43:10( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Chris Murphy

Chris Murphy

1:42:25 to 1:42:46( Edit History Discussion )

Chris Murphy: world and it makes no sense that our health care system is the inefficient, m the world. but the changes we don't need to throw out what we got. despite all this nonsense, political speak from the republicans about government takeovers, this bill -- to reset the rules of the private health care marketplace so it starts working again like it should.

Chris Murphy

1:42:47 to 1:43:07( Edit History Discussion )

Chris Murphy: so that small business can ban together to negotiate for lower prices. so that individuals will have access to tax credits t help them pay for private insurance. insurance that's fair and doesn't discriminate against them because they are sick. will fix this crisis in our health care system all on the shoulders of a reformed private system so that never again does a child fall asleep sick in his bed because his country, the

Chris Murphy

1:43:08 to 1:43:10( Edit History Discussion )

Chris Murphy: most powerful in the world, didn't have the courage t him well.

Mike Rogers

1:43:11 to 1:43:31( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: i yield back. . the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas. mr. barton: i'd like to recognize congressman frank wolf of virginia for an unanimou the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized.

Mike Rogers

1:43:15 to 1:45:00( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Mike Rogers

Mike Rogers

1:43:32 to 1:43:52( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: mr. wolf: i rise in opposition to theill. our nation is going broke. thank you. mr. barton: mr. speaker, i want man fromhe great state michigan, mr. rogers, for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. rogers: thank you, mr. speaker. there are huge consequences to

Mike Rogers

1:43:53 to 1:44:13( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: the 85% of americans who have earned their health care in this bill. not only will they get longer wait times, more expensive premiums, but at the end of that with new debts of $1.5 trillion in new spending 18 million americans won't have coverage. but more importantly, there ll be there's nothing more safer than the bo between a mother and a

Mike Rogers

1:44:14 to 1:44:34( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: that nurturing when that child is sick. and when a mother goes to the doctor under that 2,000-page bill, that relationship that they enjoy between their patient and their doctor and what that mother wants for that chi is no longer sacred different boards and

Mike Rogers

1:44:35 to 1:44:56( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: commissions, their comparative effectiveness research allows the government to force government insurance to ration and deny care. you have violated the most important trust, the most important thing that w the building block and the foundation of the values of this country. that mother, that doctor knows what's best for that child. you will find no compassion in

Mike Rogers

1:44:57 to 1:45:00( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: a federal bureaucracy. mr. speaker, i would urge the

John T. Salazar

1:45:01 to 1:45:21( Edit History Discussion )

John T. Salazar: strong rejection and the protection of that bond between doctor andatient and mother the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california. mr. waxman: mr. speaker, i yield one minute to the gentleman from colorado, mr. salazar. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. salazar: mr. speaker, i am especially pleased that this bill will help rural america.

John T. Salazar

1:45:05 to 1:46:05( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John T. Salazar

John T. Salazar

1:45:22 to 1:45:42( Edit History Discussion )

John T. Salazar: currently, physicians in rural areas are reimbursed less for medicare than their urban counterparts. h.r. 3962 will rume bu primary care physicians in rural areas, not only to equalize the disparity but to make rural communities more attractive to physicians. most of my district is considered a health professional shoage area. in my district in colorado, we have three counties with only

John T. Salazar

1:45:43 to 1:46:05( Edit History Discussion )

John T. Salazar: practicing physician. we have one county with none at all. this bill will increase the number of physicians in all my counties and improve access for 106,000 medicare beneficiaries. this bill will expand insurance coverage to 111,000 currently uninsured citizens in my district. it will help 184,000 low-income

Steve Scalise

1:46:06 to 1:46:26( Edit History Discussion )

Steve Scalise: families pay for their insurance. and it is time to fix it now. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas. mr. barton: mr. speaker, i want to recognize from the pelican state, a member of the committee, congressman scalise of new orleans for one mine. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one

Steve Scalise

1:46:10 to 1:47:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Steve Scalise

Steve Scalise

1:46:27 to 1:46:47( Edit History Discussion )

Steve Scalise: minute. mr. scalise: i want to thank the ranking member from texas for yielding. i rise in opposition to speaker pelosi's 1,990-page government takeover of health care. weighing in at nearly 20 pounds, this bill comes out to over $530 per page. and where does this bill spend that money?

Steve Scalise

1:46:48 to 1:47:08( Edit History Discussion )

Steve Scalise: well, first of all, it fails the american people. it fails those small businesses and families that are going to have to pay the $730 billion in new taxes in this bill. it fails our seniors who have to deal with over $500 billion in cuts to medicare. and it fails many of president obama's own pledges and promises he made right here on this floor, like when he said

Steve Scalise

1:47:09 to 1:47:29( Edit History Discussion )

Steve Scalise: if you make less than $250,000 a year you won't pay any new taxes, and i quote, not a dime. in this bill there's over $20 billion of taxes, new taxes, just on people who have no insurance. the president have said multiple times if you like what you have you can keep it. unfortunately, this bill fails the president's promise because it allows the health care czar

Steve Scalise

1:47:30 to 1:47:30( Edit History Discussion )

Steve Scalise: to take away your insurance

Betty Sue Sutton

1:47:31 to 1:47:51( Edit History Discussion )

Betty Sue Sutton: even if you like it. it's so bad that even when we brought our amendment that says all members of congress have to abide by this bill, they actually refused a vote on this amendment. we need to defeat this legislation and do real reform. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the chair would announce that the gentleman from texas has 11 1/2 minutes remaing. the gentleman from california 6

Betty Sue Sutton

1:47:35 to 1:49:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Betty Sue Sutton

Betty Sue Sutton

1:47:52 to 1:48:13( Edit History Discussion )

Betty Sue Sutton: 1/4. mr. waxman: yield one minute to a member of our committee, the gentlelady from ohio, betty sutton. the speaker pro tempore: the ge one minute. american people have been waiting for this day, a day that we will finally pass a health care bill that will work for and with them, that will

Betty Sue Sutton

1:48:14 to 1:48:36( Edit History Discussion )

Betty Sue Sutton: provide them with access to more aforwardable, quality care -- affordable, quality care, care they can count on. mr. speaker, they have been waiting for us to put an end to the egregious, discriminatory practices of insurance companies who deny covage based on pre-existing conditions and plays -- place

Betty Sue Sutton

1:48:37 to 1:49:00( Edit History Discussion )

Betty Sue Sutton: caps on coverage on accessing care they need just when they need it the most. today, we ask to improve the employer-based coverage for 420,000 residents in my district, and to improve medicare for 107,000 beneficiaries, and to move to close the prescription drug doughnut hole for seniors across this country. yes, mr. speaker, the american

Betty Sue Sutton

1:49:01 to 1:49:21( Edit History Discussion )

Betty Sue Sutton: people have today we ask for a health care system that will work for and with them. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas. mr. barton: could i ask how much time? you said a minute ago but i was not listening. the speaker pro tempore: the

Betty Sue Sutton

1:49:22 to 1:49:31( Edit History Discussion )

Betty Sue Sutton: chair is shocked. the gentleman from texas has 11 1/2 minutes remaing. the gentman from california has 5 1/4 minutes remaining. mr. barton: thank you, mr.

Michael C. Burgess

1:49:32 to 1:49:53( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: speaker. i was listening to my distinguished friends on the majority. i would like to recognize a member of the committee, one of our doctors, our physicians, the honorable chael burgess of lewisville, texas, e minute. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one mr. burgess: i thank the

Michael C. Burgess

1:49:40 to 1:50:55( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Michael C. Burgess

Michael C. Burgess

1:49:54 to 1:50:14( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: gentleman for yielding. you know, last spring and summer as we got into this debate, america's doctors were pretty clear what they wanted to see if congress was going to undertake health care reform. they wanted to see some relief in the medical justice system. they wanted to see some medical liability reform. they desperately needed a fix to the payment formula in medicare that shows reductions in medicare reimbursement rates every year for as far as the

Michael C. Burgess

1:50:15 to 1:50:36( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: eye could see and the antitrust relief. after all, we are going to ask our doctors to be part of the brave new world of health care reform. the least we can do is talk amongst themselves about the best way to deliver high-quality care at low cost. but what happened? antitrust, not in this bill. s.g.r., we'll take this up some point in the future. medical liability, a smidgen of

Michael C. Burgess

1:50:37 to 1:50:57( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: medical liability reform in this bill. now, texas has done in the last six years what this country needs to realize would be the way to go forward in medical liability reform. caps on noneconomic damages have worked in the state of texas. you don't have to take my word for it. there are almost 15,000 new physicians that have come to

1:50:58 to 1:50:59( Edit History Discussion )

when this was enacted.

1:51:00 to 1:51:21( Edit History Discussion )

82 counties the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. mr. burgess: have doctors that did not have them before. and e.r. services have seen significant increases. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. mr. burgess: this coress should -- th gentleman's time has expired. mr. burgess: i yield back my time. the speaker pro tempore: the

1:51:22 to 1:51:42( Edit History Discussion )

gentleman from california. mr. waxman: mr. speaker, for unanimous consent request i yield to the gentleman from iowa, mr. boswell. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized. mr. boswell: i ask unanimous consent to revise and extend my remarks to support this bill and people in my district are waiting and so is my state and our co yield one minute to the

1:51:43 to 1:52:04( Edit History Discussion )

gentleman from virginia, mr. colloquy. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. pierriello: mr. chairman, i recognize what this bill does to make health care more affordable. i just want to clarify for the record the maternity care is a re essent all individual insurance and

1:52:05 to 1:52:26( Edit History Discussion )

employer insurance across th country. mr. waxman: will the gentleman yield? yes, that is a correct statement. mr. pierluisi: the prena postnatal care pierriello: the prenatal and postnatal care is included? mr. waxman: will the gentleman yield? yes, you are correct in this statement.

1:52:27 to 1:52:48( Edit History Discussion )

mr. pierriello: thank you for clarifying this. mr. waxman: i reserve the balance of the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas. mr. barton: is it my turn, mr. speaker? mr. speaker, i want to recognize a member of the committee, a proud grandfather from the great state of arizona, congressman john shadegg from phoenix for one

Personal tools

MetaVid is a non-profit project of UC Santa Cruz and the Sunlight Foundation. Learn more About MetaVid

The C-SPAN logo and other servicemarks that may be found in video content are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Metavid