Metavid

Video archive of the US Congress

Senate Proceeding on Jul 6th, 2009 :: 1:52:10 to 2:05:45
Total video length: 5 hours 12 minutes Stream Tools: Stream Overview | Edit Time

Note: MetaVid video transcripts may contain inaccuracies, help us build a more perfect archive

Download OptionsEmbed Video

Views:22 Duration: 0:13:35 Discussion

Previous speech: Next speech:

John Barrasso

1:51:54 to 1:52:16( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: quorum call: the presiding officer: the senator from wyoming. mr. barrasso: i ask unanimous consent to speak in morning business and the quorum call be dispensed with. the presiding officer: without objection. mr. barrasso:republicans and democrats agree that we need and want health kay refume. having practiced medicine for two decades in wyoming, i know that doing nothing is simply not

John Barrasso

1:52:10 to 2:05:45( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John Barrasso

John Barrasso

1:52:17 to 1:52:37( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: an option. but let me tell you from experience the devil is always in the detaissmen we must be careful, thoughtful and deliberate about the changes that we make. health care is a very complex and an intensely personal issue.

John Barrasso

1:52:38 to 1:52:59( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: it deserves a serious, open, and a transparent national debate. any change is gng to impact millions and millions of american families. these are people of our nation. these are not nameless or faceless statistics. these are husbands, mothers, neighbors. these are our wives, our

John Barrasso

1:53:00 to 1:53:22( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: friends, and our coworkers. these americans are children, the nation's most precious resources. we must act, but still at issue is whether congress will act without sacrificing care system's greatest strengths. and what are those strengths? the freedom to choose your own doctor; the freedom to choose the hospital that you want; and

John Barrasso

1:53:23 to 1:53:44( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: the freedom to choose the health care plan that fits you and fits your family's needs. mr. president, i travel home to wyoming every weekend. i was there yesterday and one of the top issues that i hear about is health care. the people of wyoming are concerned about the cost of their health care. many families worry that they will lose the health care

John Barrasso

1:53:45 to 1:54:06( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: coverage that they currently have. still others can't afford health insurance at all. this is what's wrong with the current health care system. this is when we need to fix -- this is what we need to fix. wyoming families want to purchase health insurance coverage at an affordable price. they do not want to be denied coverage because of preexisting conditions.

John Barrasso

1:54:07 to 1:54:27( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: they don't want to lose coverage if they change jobs. but, most of all, these families do not want washington telling them -- wo want washington telling them -- do not want washington telling them who they have to see for their medical care. everyone should have the freedom to choose the doctor, the

John Barrasso

1:54:28 to 1:54:49( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: hospital, and the health care plan that they want. no washington bureaucrat should ever be allowed to deny that right. some in congress continue focusing solely on government solutions. they want washington to take over health care. some in congress want to create a government-run health care plan.

John Barrasso

1:54:50 to 1:55:12( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: their plan creates a government-run insurance model that could limit patient choices, eliminate personal freedoms and decrease the quality of care. what starts out at one option could quickly lead to being the only option, and we all know how this happens. unlike regular health insurance, government health plans have

John Barrasso

1:55:13 to 1:55:33( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: unlimited access to taxpayer money. they use the known tempo susubsidize the cost of services. according to the lewin group, 119 million americans would lose the coverage that they currently have if they have a government-run system.

John Barrasso

1:55:34 to 1:55:54( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: i know some the senate and administration keep saying, if you like your insurance coverage, you will get to keep it. the lewin group data provides otherwise. their substitute shows that businesses will face a situation war it's cheaper for them ensure their employees through the government-run plan so employers will then transfer

John Barrasso

1:55:55 to 1:56:16( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: their workers from the private insurance that they currently have and may like to this now washington-run government plan. so where's t personal choice? at this point, the individual has no option. the government-run plan is their option, is their plan, unless that person changes jobs to an employer who afford to offer private

John Barrasso

1:56:17 to 1:56:38( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: coverage. so, what happened to the "if i like my health insurance plan offered by my employer i would be able to keep it?" well that promise is out the window. now, some say we can create safeguards that will ensure a level playing field between private insurance and a government-run plan. well, as a doctor, i can tell you from personal experience

John Barrasso

1:56:39 to 1:56:59( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: that the government will never, ever compete on a level playing field with private business. washington will never let its health care plan go bankrupt -- never. it'll lose money. it'll hide costs. and uimately taxpayers will pay the difference. private plans will not enjoy

John Barrasso

1:57:00 to 1:57:21( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: this same kind of support. that is exactly how the heavy hand of government can drive out competition. so, how does government compete with private business? well, congressman mike pence of indiana summed it up pretty well. he said the government competes with private business the way an alligator competes with a duck.

John Barrasso

1:57:22 to 1:57:42( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: supporters of a government-run takeover of health care says the plan will keep costs low. how? by paying hospitals, doctors, nurses, home health agencies, care facilities less than private insurers pay. this so should sound familiar. this is what already happens with medicare and with medicaid.

John Barrasso

1:57:43 to 1:58:04( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: any participating medicare or medicaid provider will tell you that today, right now, doctors and hospitals have to shift costs onto private insurers just to keep their doors open. the cost-shift to make up the difference between what a procedure costs and what the government is willing to pay for it. knows what they call cost shifting.

John Barrasso

1:58:05 to 1:58:25( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: we see it every day. a government hft run plan will not encourage it will take away your access to private health insurance. the private plans that millions of americans have program this they lirk the one tha--the program that they like, the one they want to keep, will be gone.

John Barrasso

1:58:26 to 1:58:46( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: the only choice remaining will be the government plan. so what does this mea to someone who is listening in to the patient? it means politicians making health care decisions, not patients making those decisions with their doctors. it deciding if you can have the hip or the knee procedure that you need. it means the government saying, you

John Barrasso

1:58:47 to 1:59:09( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: government treatment because it's too expensive or because you are old. it means washington restricting your or your child's access medical equipment, it means preventing testing dlairks it means diagnosis dlairks it means treatment delays. delayed care is denied care, and

John Barrasso

1:59:10 to 1:59:30( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: we do not want that in america. take a close look at what is going on in canada right now. last ophthalmologists, eye doctors, there is no waiting list for people needing cataract surgery. thenal beer t.s.a. cash-strapped government made a decision --

John Barrasso

1:59:31 to 1:59:51( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: they made a decision that they said, hey, we're going to arbitrarily lower the number of cataract oppose rigs that we pay for. they just arbitrarily said we're going to pay for 2,000 fewer cataract operations this year in alberta than we did last year. so what does had a pean for the people there?

John Barrasso

1:59:52 to 2:00:12( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: many patients have to wait a year for treatment, a year. why? the cutback to cancel a of the operationings that they had scheduled on people with moderately severe cataract conditions. so now they only book the most severe cases. ophthalmologists are

John Barrasso

2:00:13 to 2:00:34( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: concentrating their efforts only on the patients who are about to go bnd. not the people who have a hard time seeing, the people who are about to go blind. patients in alberta have to almost go blind to get cataract surgery. is that the kind of medical care that we want for americans? absolutely not. americans should strive to offer

John Barrasso

2:00:35 to 2:00:55( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: its citizens the highest quality, most timely health care services in the world. that means that americans should not have to wait weeks at a time for tests and treatments they need. it means no one should be denied health care services because of government limits or government restrictions. it means no government bureaucrat should interfere in

John Barrasso

2:00:56 to 2:01:16( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: the doctor-patient relationship. currently the senate "help" committee has been debating a health reform plan that has been put forth by senators kennedy and dodd. well, the nonpartisan congressional budget office told us -- first it told us that the kennedy-dodd plan increases

John Barrasso

2:01:17 to 2:01:37( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: spending by more tha than $1.3 trillion in the first 10 years. once it's ful operational a 10-year fee would be closer t to $2.6 trillion. the number was staggering. people cried sticker shock. what did they do? they tweaked it around a little bit and came out with a new estimate. well, they're just guessing much even more disturb something that the plan is incomplete.

John Barrasso

2:01:38 to 2:01:58( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: the congressional budget office still has additional policies to score, to come up with a price tag on. clearly this estimate does not reflect the bill's true cost because they left out medicaid, something th've been forcing on to the states. and governors around the country have been crushed by these medicaid increased fees and

John Barrasso

2:01:59 to 2:02:19( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: increased expenses. so 10 years, trillions of dollars, congressional budget office also tells us that this plan only refuses the number of people who do not have insurance by 17 million. that leaves over 30 million americans still without health insurance and they're spending $1 trillion.

John Barrasso

2:02:20 to 2:02:40( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: finally the congressional budget office indicates that about 15 million people would actually lose the insurance that they have now, be forced off their employer-paid for insurance under this trillion dollar plan. well, this, to me, this kennedy-dodd plan suffers from

John Barrasso

2:02:41 to 2:03:01( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: what i call the three's, it costs too much, it covers too few, and it causes too many people who already have insurance to lose the coverage that they have. now, some in congress believe that unlesse completely dismantle the current health care system and build it up in the image of big government, well, then reform, they say, is

John Barrasso

2:03:02 to 2:03:22( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: simply not worth doing. i disagree. government bureaucracy that has given us the department of motor vehicles, do not want those people controlling our medical decisions. americans do not bureaucratic hassles, we don't want long waits and we don't want restrictions on our medical

John Barrasso

2:03:23 to 2:03:43( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: care. what we need is a serious transparent health care debate. that's what americans want. they want us to listen to their ideas, their concerns, their suggestions. the only way they can give us their ideas, concerns, and, specifically, their suggestions

John Barrasso

2:03:44 to 2:04:05( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: about a health care bill is if they actually get to read the bill. whether or not we should reform our health care system is no longer in question. americans have answered with a resounding yes, and they don't want to continue to wait. they want simple, practical, affordable changes now.

John Barrasso

2:04:06 to 2:04:27( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: changes like prohibiting the use of preexisting conditions. changes like allowing people to take their health insurance with them when they switch jobs. madam president, you have young -- a young family, i have a young family. they're going to have seven or eight jobs over the course of their lifetime. they need to be able to take their insurance with them. we need to have changes like

John Barrasso

2:04:28 to 2:04:48( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: fering premium breaks making healthy lifestyle choices. changes like the same tax breaks for people who buy their own insurance that the big companies get when they pay for insurance for their employees, we need families to have the same tax breaks. we need changes like allowing people to shop across statelines to look for better deals on

John Barrasso

2:04:49 to 2:05:10( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: keeping their costs down. i want to continue to come forward with commonsense ideas. i want the majority in congress to work with me and with members of my party on a bipartisan health reform plan. that's the need. that's the need expecting. that's what i would like to do.

John Barrasso

2:05:11 to 2:05:33( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: we cannot simply put government in charge of health care and put bureaucrats in between patients and their doctors. with that, madam president, i yield the floor and suggest the the presiding officer: the clerk

John Barrasso

2:05:34 to 2:05:39( Edit History Discussion )

John Barrasso: will call the roll.

There is currently no text in this page. You can search for this page title in other pages, search the related logs, or edit this page.

Personal tools

MetaVid is a non-profit project of UC Santa Cruz and the Sunlight Foundation. Learn more About MetaVid

The C-SPAN logo and other servicemarks that may be found in video content are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Metavid